Essay: Isaiah Berlin’s View of Thinkers

N.B. This is an automated translation of the original Swedish text.

Isaiah Berlin’s essay The Hedgehog and the Fox (1953) gave rise to one of the more unusual cognitive classifications of human thinkers in intellectual history. The essay was originally an examination of Leo Tolstoy’s personality in relation to his thinking. Berlin argued that Tolstoy was a fox who actually wanted to be a hedgehog. His own thinking prevented him from adopting a different perspective. Tolstoy’s literary work encompassed so much that a more narrowly focused approach to writing became impossible.

Berlin divided thinkers into two main categories: hedgehogs and foxes. Drawing on the ancient saying, “The fox knows many things, but the hedgehog knows one big thing,” Berlin developed a framework for classifying thinkers into these two groups.

The hedgehog views the world through a single overarching idea, thought, or principle that takes precedence over everything else. Such thinkers are often relatively uncompromising in their assumptions; doubt is largely absent because all arguments are interpreted through the lens of their fundamental, holistic premise. Examples of such thinkers include Plato, Dante, and Hegel, all of whom constructed grand intellectual systems within which everything could be synthesized.

Foxes, by contrast, represent the opposite tendency. Their pursuit of knowledge can unfold on several different levels and toward a variety of goals. They are attracted to the complexity of the world and see no reason why their curiosity should not lead them into unexplored intellectual territory. Examples include Aristotle, Balzac, and Goethe. All were men whose intellectual antennae were attuned to wherever new ideas might lead them. An underlying principle might well have existed, but it took a secondary role to the direction in which their pursuit of knowledge happened to lead them.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Please reload

Please Wait